Reactive Dogs & Trigger Stacking: The Stress Bucket Analogy

What is Trigger Stacking in Dogs?

If you have a reactive dog, you’ve probably noticed that some days they can handle a lot, while other days the smallest thing sets them off. This isn’t random — it’s often due to trigger stacking.

Trigger stacking happens when your dog experiences multiple stressors in a short period of time. These stressors can be positive (excitement) or negative (fear, frustration), but they all add to your dog’s stress levels. When those levels get too high, your dog’s coping ability runs out, and a reactive outburst can happen.

The Bucket Analogy for Stress

Imagine your dog’s stress levels as a bucket of water:

• Every stressor adds water to the bucket.

• Some stressors add just a splash, others pour in a lot.

• Once the bucket is full, it overflows — that overflow is your dog’s reaction.

Here’s the important part: both good stress and bad stress go into the same bucket. The body processes them in similar ways, releasing stress hormones like adrenaline and cortisol. Even a fun day can fill the bucket higher than you think.

Good Stress vs Bad Stress in Dogs

Examples of Good Stress (Eustress)

These are things your dog might enjoy but that still add to their stress bucket:

• Meeting a favourite person

• Playing a high-energy game of fetch or tug

• Visiting a new, stimulating environment

• Learning new tricks during an exciting training session

Examples of Bad Stress (Distress)

These are experiences your dog may find challenging or unpleasant:

• Seeing a strange dog that makes them nervous

• Hearing fireworks or loud bangs

• Being handled by a stranger at the vet

• Feeling frustrated when on-lead and unable to greet another dog

Even though good stress feels positive in the moment, it still adds to the bucket and takes time to drain away. This is why a fun outing followed by an unexpected trigger can still lead to a reaction.

Why Trigger Stacking Matters for Reactive Dogs

Reactive dogs often have buckets that fill more quickly. This could be because of:

• Past negative experiences

• Lower stress tolerance

• Ongoing anxiety or arousal

A normal walk might include several small stressors: a jogger passing by, a barking dog in the distance, a loud car. Each one adds to the bucket. If a “big” trigger happens when the bucket is already nearly full, it can push your dog over the edge into barking, lunging, or shutting down.

Understanding this helps explain why your dog might react one day and not another — it often comes down to how full their bucket already is.

How to Help Your Dog Avoid Trigger Stacking

• Watch for early signs of stress such as lip licking, yawning, tense posture, or turning away.

• Allow recovery time after big days, even if they seemed happy and excited at the time.

• Manage exposure to known triggers where possible to prevent overfilling the bucket.

• Build resilience through positive reinforcement training, predictable routines, and providing a safe space to relax.

Sometimes the best thing you can do for your dog is give them a quiet day to let the bucket empty before adding more experiences.

Key Takeaway

Both good and bad stress add to your dog’s bucket. By understanding and managing trigger stacking, you can help your reactive dog feel calmer, safer, and more in control — and that means a happier life for both of you.

If you’re in the Stoke-on-Trent area and need help with a reactive dog, I offer 1-1 training sessions using only kind, force-free methods - ’https://www.pawsomecanines.co.uk/reactive-dog-tra

ining

 Together, we can create a plan that reduces your dog's stress and builds their confidence.